I'm really trying to get the hang of winged liner. It's been a journey! I tried to make it a little easier on myself today by smudging out the blue on my lower lash line, and using that as a guide for the wing. On my lid, I used Asteria by Sugarpill. The lower waterline & lash line is Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Radium, smudged out with MAC Cosmetics - A Bluer Blue. I also had MAC's Frozen White pigment on the tear duct, which I wish showed up better in the picture!! Mascara: NYC Big Bold Mascara with Buxom Lash. The liner is NYC liquid liner.